ageyn logo

Best Weight Loss Programs

At Ageyn, our editorial team upholds independence and objectivity. To support our journalistic efforts and offer free content to our audience, we receive financial support from advertisers on the Ageyn Health platform. This funding comes from two primary sources. Firstly, we receive payments for allocated advertising spaces, influencing the placement and presentation of these advertisements on our site. However, it's important to note that not all companies or products in the market are featured on our site. Secondly, we incorporate affiliate links in some of our articles, which may generate revenue for our site if you click on them.

The financial support from advertisers does not sway the guidance or recommendations provided by our editorial team in our articles, nor does it affect any other editorial content on Ageyn Health. We strive to deliver accurate, current information we believe will be of interest to you. However, Ageyn Health cannot assure the completeness of this information, nor do we make any claims or warranties about its accuracy or applicability.

tooltip arrow
Menu

10,000+
subscribers

Stay informed on the latest cosmetic treatments, anti-aging, health and wellness research by subscribing to Ageyn's newsletter.

Your submission has been received! Learn more about our IRB-approved treatment protocol here.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Advertisement.

Weight Watchers vs Intermittent Fasting: Comparison (2024)

Comparing Weight Watchers and Intermittent Fasting for weight loss. Discover key factors like lifestyle compatibility, cost, scientific evidence, and safety precautions to make an informed choice. Find out which method aligns with your health goals today.

Article Summary

Comparing Weight Watchers and Intermittent Fasting for weight loss. Discover key factors like lifestyle compatibility, cost, scientific evidence, and safety precautions to make an informed choice. Find out which method aligns with your health goals today.

information button

Rob's extensive expertise in evidence-based weight loss interventions, backed by rigorous peer-reviewed research, has established him as a credible authority in the field. As a clinical research associate (CRA), Rob has tested new applications for their effectiveness, risks and benefits to ensure that they are safe for consumers.

tooltip arrow

Article updated on:

February 20, 2024

Why You Can Trust Ageyn

With the intention of making health information easily comprehensible, our editorial process has been carefully crafted. Our writers and editors are all veteran clinical research specialists who strive to demystify complex research studies, data, and medical terminology to guarantee that the information is precise, sympathetic, and applicable so you can make the right health decisions.

  • Weight Watchers $5 FLASH SALE. Join millions of Americans who have experienced success.
LEARN MORE →

On WeightWatchers website.

Commissions we earn from partner links on this page do not affect our opinions or evaluations. Our editorial content is based on thorough research and guidance from our health research experts.

View Our Other Weight Loss Recommendations

  • Simple to follow, pre-packaged meals
  • Fasting backed by over 20 years of scientific research
  • Flexible purchase options, including HSA/FSA eligibility and subscription savings
No items found.

Second Best Diet App

  • Click for Special Partner Offer
  • Powered by the creator of #1 doctor-recommended weight-loss program*
  • Available in the award-winning WW app with features that simplify your journey

9.8

Excellent Rating

LEARN MORE →

On WeightWatchers' Website

Lose Weight With Fast Mimicking

  • Fasting backed by over 20 years of scientific research
  • Flexible purchase options, including HSA/FSA eligibility and subscription savings
  • Simple to follow, pre-packaged meals

9.9

Excellent Rating

LEARN MORE →

On Prolons' Website

Best Quick Fat Burner Pills

  • Reducing Hunger Cravings attributed to Capsimax
  • Formulated with science-based clinically tested ingredients to help make the weight-loss process easier and more efficient
  • Gluten-free, Non-GMO, no artificial sweeteners or colors

9.2

Very Good

CHECK PRICE →

Transparent Labs

Quick Comparison
& Insights

Intermittent fasting produces similar weight loss as Weight Watchers but may be easier for some people to follow long-term due to fewer dietary restrictions.

ASPECT
Intermittent Fasting
Weight Watchers
COST
Cost-effective as it does not require purchasing special foods
$23-43/month (discounts common)
FLEXIBILITY
Several popular methods, like 16:8, 5:2, and alternate day fasting
Points system to encourage balanced choices
SUPPORT
Consulting a doctor, especially if you have any health conditions, can ensure safety
In-person meetings, online tools, and social media groups
EFFECTIVENESS
Results vary based on the individual and specifics of the method.
Multiple peer-reviewed studies showing effectiveness
APPROACH
Intermittent fasting can be cost-effective, flexible, and effective for health when approached incrementally and sustainably.
Balanced, personalized approach using a points system
GET STARTED
Get Started →

Intermittent Fasting

Get Started →

Weight Watchers

Learn more about our favourite weight loss program for 2024.
Get your personalized plan with Noom today.
Quick Comparison
& Insights

Intermittent fasting produces similar weight loss as Weight Watchers but may be easier for some people to follow long-term due to fewer dietary restrictions.

COST
Intermittent Fasting
Cost-effective as it does not require purchasing special foods
Weight Watchers
$23-43/month (discounts common)
FLEXIBILITY
Intermittent Fasting
Points system to encourage balanced choices
Weight Watchers
Points system to encourage balanced choices
SUPPORT
Intermittent Fasting
Consulting a doctor, especially if you have any health conditions, can ensure safety
Weight Watchers
In-person meetings, online tools, and social media groups
EFFECTIVENESS
Intermittent Fasting
Results vary based on the individual and specifics of the method.
Weight Watchers
Multiple peer-reviewed studies showing effectiveness
APPROACH
Intermittent Fasting
Intermittent fasting can be cost-effective, flexible, and effective for health when approached incrementally and sustainably.
Weight Watchers
Balanced, personalized approach using a points system
Get Started →

Weight Watchers

Intermittent fasting (IF) and Weight Watchers are two popular diet approaches that have gained considerable mainstream traction in recent years.

As methods for weight loss and health improvement, each offers unique strategies that lead many to wonder how they compare.

This article aims to provide a comprehensive, evidence-based overview of intermittent fasting versus Weight Watchers, detailing their key differences, pros and cons, and their efficacy for weight loss.

Intermittent Fasting vs Weight Watchers

Intermittent Fasting

Intermittent fasting is an eating pattern that revolves around cycles of fasting and eating. Unlike many traditional diets, IF focuses more on when you eat rather than what you eat. The most commonly followed IF protocols include:

  • 16/8 method: Fasting for 16 hours a day and restricting eating to an 8-hour window.
  • 5:2 diet: Eating normally for five days per week, while limiting calories to 500-600 on the other two days.
  • Alternate day fasting: A regimen of fasting every other day.
  • Time-restricted feeding: Limiting eating to a specific number of hours each day.

Studies have suggested that intermittent fasting has potential benefits that extend beyond mere weight loss. These include enhancing fat burning, improving metabolic health, lowering blood pressure and cholesterol, and even cognitive benefits like better memory. However, it's essential to note that more research is still needed on the long-term effects of IF on humans.

Weight Watchers vs Intermittent Fasting

Weight Watchers

Weight Watchers, also known as WW, is a science-backed, commercial diet program designed to facilitate weight loss through lifestyle changes. The core components of this program include:

  • ProPoints system: Foods are assigned point values based on their nutritional content. Each individual has a personalized daily point budget.
  • Group support: Access to in-person workshops and an online community.
  • Behavioral modification: Focus on changing mindsets for long-term weight management.
  • Activity tracking: The FitPoints system encourages physical exercise.
  • Flexible eating: No food is off-limits as long as it fits within your daily points.

According to various studies, WW is effective for gradual, sustainable weight loss and also shows promise in reducing risk factors associated with cardiovascular diseases.

Weight Loss Effects

Both IF and WW can serve as effective tools for weight loss, albeit through different mechanisms. Intermittent fasting naturally results in a reduced caloric intake by confining eating to limited time frames, leading to 3-8% weight loss over periods of 3-24 weeks. On the other hand, Weight Watchers forces a daily calorie deficit through its points system, with its users experiencing around 5-6% of body weight loss over 6-12 months.

For those who are more ambitious, combining the point system of Weight Watchers with the time-restricted eating of intermittent fasting may offer synergistic benefits.

Pros and Cons

Pros of Intermittent Fasting:

Cons of Intermittent Fasting:

  • Hunger pangs during fasting periods
  • Some may find long fasts difficult
  • Potential for overindulging during eating windows
  • Lack of a built-in support system
  • Uncertainties about long-term safety

Pros of Weight Watchers:

Cons of Weight Watchers:

  • Point tracking can become tedious
  • Costs can add up due to subscription
  • Some may find it restrictive
  • Promotion of some processed diet foods
  • May offer fewer metabolic benefits compared to IF

Suitability and Lifestyle Compatibility

Deciding which method is ideal for you comes down to understanding your unique needs and lifestyle patterns. Intermittent Fasting may be more suitable for those with:

  • Busy schedules: If you often skip meals or don't have time for regular meal prep, the simplicity of fasting fits right in.
  • Aversion to tracking: If you dislike calorie or point-counting, IF doesn’t require these.
  • Metabolic goals: Those looking for metabolic benefits like improved insulin sensitivity might prefer IF.
  • Diet history: If you've failed with calorie-counting diets, IF offers a different approach.
  • Meal preference: Ideal for those who prefer fewer, larger meals.

On the other hand, Weight Watchers might be the better option for:

  • Peer Support: The WW community can be invaluable for staying accountable.
  • Flexibility: If you want more structured guidance without restrictive food bans, WW provides it.
  • Emotional eating: WW's behavioral focus can help address the underlying triggers of overeating.
  • Eating Patterns: Better suited for those who prefer frequent smaller meals.
  • Sustainable Results: If gradual, long-term weight loss is your goal, WW has a proven track record.
The bottom line? Both have merits, and neither is inherently superior. The best program is the one you can stick to in the long run. Consider trying each approach to determine which aligns with your lifestyle.

Safety and Precautions

Both methods are generally considered safe for most healthy adults, as stated by Harvard Health and Weight Watchers' own safety guidelines. However, caution is advised for:

  • Diabetics or those with blood sugar issues
  • Pregnant or breastfeeding women
  • Adolescents and children
  • Individuals with a history of disordered eating
  • People with gastrointestinal issues or nutritional deficiencies

Always monitor your body's signals and consult a healthcare provider if attempting either method under specific medical conditions.

Cost Comparison

Intermittent Fasting: Absolutely free unless you opt for specialized apps or coaching.

Weight Watchers: Subscription fees range from $19 to $44 per month depending on the plan. Extra charges apply for in-person workshops.

Scientific Evidence

The scientific community is increasingly interested in both IF and WW. Research shows:

  • Intermittent Fasting: Several studies indicate 3-8% weight loss over 3-24 weeks along with improved metabolic markers. However, long-term trials are still needed.
  • Weight Watchers: Systematic reviews suggest average weight loss of 5-6% at 6 months and 3-4% at one year, along with reductions in LDL cholesterol and blood pressure.

Limited studies exist comparing the two head-to-head. Thus far, they suggest similar weight loss benefits, emphasizing that the best method depends on individual preferences and adherence.

Expert Recommendations

Experts generally agree that both methods can be effective. Intermittent Fasting is best for motivated individuals comfortable with fasting periods. Start with shorter fasts and adjust based on your body's responses. For Weight Watchers, the built-in support system and educational components make it ideal for those looking for a more structured plan.

Regardless of the method, making incremental lifestyle changes focused on long-term sustainability is key. Both approaches emphasize the importance of meeting nutritional needs through whole foods rather than relying on supplements or processed foods.

Your Choice, Your Health

To sum up, Intermittent Fasting and Weight Watchers offer distinct pathways to weight loss, each with its own set of advantages and drawbacks. While Weight Watchers provides a well-structured, supportive environment for gradual weight loss, Intermittent Fasting offers flexibility and emerging health benefits.

The optimal choice will depend on your personal needs, lifestyle, and health goals. Combining aspects of both — like IF's fasting periods with WW's point tracking — might offer a synergistic effect for those seeking to optimize their weight loss journey.

WeightWatchers Clinic's Innovative Weight Loss Approach

WeightWatchers Clinic offers a unique weight loss program, blending prescription medication and lifestyle changes. This method is especially effective for individuals facing weight loss challenges due to biological reasons. Members report an average weight loss of 15% over a 26-week period.

  • Medications Used: Includes GLP-1 receptor agonists like Semaglutide, Liraglutide, and Tirzepatide (weekly injections), and Naltrexone-Bupropion (oral).
  • Insurance Support: The clinic assists in finding cost-effective medication options through insurance.
  • Personalized Care: Program features individualized clinician care and a WeightWatchers membership.
  • Holistic Approach: Focuses on combining medical, nutritional, and lifestyle strategies for effective weight management.

The WeightWatchers Clinic stands out as a holistic solution for effective weight management, particularly for those who struggle with conventional weight loss methods.  Get started with Weight Watchers today.

{{auto1="/styling2"}}

Explore our Favourite Weight Loss Programs

Best Overall Diet App 2024

  • Prioritizes a balanced relationship with food
  • Weight, food and exercise logging tool to manage your health
  • $70/mo or $209/year with alternate options available
  • Over 45 million downloads and 45k+ 5-star reviews

9.9

Excellent Rating

TAKE Your QUIZ

On Nooms' Website

View Our Other Diet Recommendations

Best Quick Fat Burner Pills

  • Reducing Hunger Cravings attributed to Capsimax
  • Formulated with science-based clinically tested ingredients to help make the weight-loss process easier and more efficient
  • Gluten-free, Non-GMO, no artificial sweeteners or colors

9.2

Very Good

CHECK PRICE →

Transparent Labs

Lose Weight With Fast Mimicking

  • Fasting backed by over 20 years of scientific research
  • Flexible purchase options, including HSA/FSA eligibility and subscription savings
  • Simple to follow, pre-packaged meals

9.9

Excellent Rating

LEARN MORE →

On Prolons' Website

  • Simple to follow, pre-packaged meals
  • Fasting backed by over 20 years of scientific research
  • Flexible purchase options, including HSA/FSA eligibility and subscription savings
No items found.

(Now w/ GLP-1 Medications)

  • 15% Average body weight lost with Rx meds*
  • Powered by the creator of #1 doctor-recommended weight-loss program*
  • Available in the award-winning WW app with features that simplify your journey

9.9

Excellent

LEARN MORE →

On WeightWatchers' Website

Our Weight Loss APP Recommendation

weight watchers logo

Weight Loss For Real Life

check icon
63% of the weight lost in a 52-week WeightWatchers program was maintained at two years.
check icon
Simple, flexible approach with a Points® system and easy tracking in the WW app
check icon
No boring meals with 12,000+ recipes and a restaurant database
GET STARTED →
Weight Watchers App Phone
Get Started →

On Weight Watchers Website.

Get the #1 doctor-recommended weight loss app

Weight Watchers $5 FLASH SALE. Join millions of Americans who have experienced success.

LEARN MORE →
On WeightWatchers website.
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

Get the #1 doctor-recommended weight loss app

Weight Watchers $5 FLASH SALE. Join millions of Americans who have experienced success.

Unlock Mystery Discount
00
Hrs
00
Min
00
Sec